Genre, Worthless Waffle

Is fantasy really a genre?

I hear your collective gasp! How is this even a question?! Where have you been all these Tolkien and Game of Thrones filled Cinema/ TV evenings over the last erm…19 years?!

I have been glued to the screens of course! Read all the books and have properly geeked out! But every time I tried to write my own fantasy stories they kind of came up short. I never really knew what to write about…and that’s because of what I know now:

Fantasy is not a genre in itself…it’s a component of genre.

To be precise, it’s actually an indicator for how much a reader should prepare to suspend their disbelief when reading the story. Whether they should expect a romance, action adventure, coming of age etc. aside from the fantasy stuff is really down to other essential genre components. It appears that genre is not a thing…it’s a construct.

The term fantasy alone is not enough to describe your genre and tell your reader what your work is about. Check out the genre clover by Shawn Coyne to see what helped me better understand fantasy and its relationship with genre.

See ya next time 😉

If you found this article helpful, thoroughly disagree or have no idea what all this has to do with a clover, leave a reply in the comments below.

Standard
Author Business, Writing Process

Is genre writing ‘selling out’?

As a lurker in the shadows, monitoring the online forums and social media discussions concerned with writing is a curious ping-pong-like experience. Not surprising in an area of interest which so heavily depends on the personal experiences of individuals trying to figure things out. Just about any claim made by any group of writers is almost instantly opposed by another.

However, there is one thing that most writers seem to readily agree on: ‘selling out’ is a bad, BAD thing. Real writers shouldn’t compromise quality for profit. Those who do (the hucksters) shall be ostracised from the writing community along with their questionable tactics.

I share this belief. Get-rich-quick? Not here, not with us! So, if writing to market and jumping on trends are outlawed practices…where does it leave genre? After all, writing within a genre and writing to market have their similarities. Both require the writer to pay attention to established conventions and craft a story that abides by them. Otherwise you might be risking some very upset readers.

Wherever you might stand on this, I have done my research and here’s my take: if any of us ever want a chance to get our books in front of readers, we need to be able to explain what we write about. Genre accomplishes just that. It defines/ classifies your work in a helpful way so your readers can find (and enjoy) your story. Mess this up and you might end up looking like a huckster after all – misleading your readers and failing to meet their expectations.

See ya next time 😉

If you are struggling with genre writing, don’t really get why it matters, or have some other thoughts to share on this, leave a reply in the comments below.

Standard